June 19, 2015

Invitations To Apply: Visiting Research Chair at McGill University



 Announcement of a Visiting Research Chair available at McGill University

Applications are invited for a one-semester or full-year Visiting Research Chair in Constitutional and Political Theory in academic year 2016-17. This fellowship for US citizens includes a $US 25,000 stipend with no teaching responsibilities.

Hosted in McGill's Research Group on Constitutional Studies ( http://www.mcgill.ca/rgcs ) and Department of Political Science (http://www.mcgill.ca/politicalscience ), this award is open to established or emerging scholars in political theory as well as legal theory or political philosophy, and is open with respect to methodology in those fields.  The Chair will pursue research in constitutionalism and constitutional theory broadly construed.  The ability to engage with scholars and students across methodologies—normative, empirical, intellectual-historical, jurisprudential, and formal, for example— is more important that particular areas of emphasis.

Sample areas of interest include: normative analyses of fundamental rights and of such basic constitutional structures as the separation of powers or federalism; democratic theory, especially as it pertains to political institutions; the history of political thought about constitutional government or constitutional forms; and questions of justice about the constitutional basic structure of a society, ranging from property and market relations to the legal organization of family life.

The Chair-holder will be in residence at RGCS, will deliver one public lecture, and will take an active part in the intellectual life of McGill, RGCS, and the Groupe de Recherche Interuniversitaire en Philosophie Politique (GRIPP).  Previous chair-holders include Andrew Rehfeld (Political Science, Washington University- St Louis), James Gardner (Law, SUNY Albany) and Erin Delaney (Law and, courtesy, Political Science, Northwestern).

Full eligibility information is available at http://www.fulbright.ca/eligibility-american-scholars/ and application infromation at http://www.fulbright.ca/programs/american-scholars/primary-awards/legal/ .  The award number is 6470.  Those interested are encouraged to contact Jacob Levy at rgcs.mcgill@gmail.com (especially for questions about thematic fit) and Michael Hawes at mhawes@fulbright.ca (especially for procedural questions) early in the application process.  Applications must be complete by August 3, 2015.


June 18, 2015

Desolate, Creepy, Suspenseful: The Second Season of "True Detective"

Alessandra Stanley reviews season 2 of HBO's True Detective for the New York Times here. She says in part:


Season 1 had two stars in the lead roles, Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson. Now there are four: Vince Vaughn is Frank Semyon, a gangster-entrepreneur; Rachel McAdams is Detective Ani Bezzerides; Colin Farrell is Detective Ray Velcoro; and Taylor Kitsch is Paul Woodrugh, a motorcycle officer with the California Highway Patrol.

That’s a lot of star power and screen charisma, but all four leads wander in a haze of gloom so unrelenting and indistinguishable that it is almost comical; their lives are master classes in misery that make the novels of James Ellroy seem like Dr. Seuss stories.

The desolate landscape of industrial sprawl in the fictional city of Vinci, just outside Los Angeles, is much bleaker than the fields and swamps of rural Louisiana. Even the show’s opening theme is creepier: the sulfurous sound of Leonard Cohen reciting the words to his song, “Nevermind.”
...
There isn’t as much versatility and contrast, but the new season has evocative scenes of its own. These are seedy, small-time cops and robbers, but their story is sometimes ennobled with almost startling touches of visual grandeur. In a louche bar where Frank conducts business with Ray, the camera frames Frank’s face against a rich green backdrop and holds there — the mix of light and dark is so painterly it looks like a Renaissance portrait.
...

“True Detective” is monochromatic and self-serious, but it builds suspense with finesse and has a keen appreciation for the poetry of political corruption and urban decay.
That makes it intriguing, just not enthralling. Then again, a second novel is sometimes a prelude to a third that truly is twice as good.

John Jay College of Criminal Justice 4th Literature and Law Conference Call For Papers

The John Jay College of Criminal Justice has issued a call for papers for its 4th Literature and Law Conference, Literature, Labor, and the Law, to be held October 30-November 1st 2015.  The submission deadline is June 30th.






The responsibility of the state described by Plato, the contracts written by Shakespeare's Shylock, or the works delving into the plight of modern laborers all explore the intersections between Literature and Law.  This conference will explore the way that literary renderings of labor concerns, broadly defined, have responded to or have influenced the law. 

Key Note Speaker:  Peter Goodrich, Professor of Law and Director of the  Law and Humanities Program at Cardozo School of Law
Peter Goodrich  has written extensively in legal history and theory, law and literature and semiotics and has authored 12 books. He is managing editor of Law and Literature, and was the founding editor of Law and Critique. His most recent book is Legal Emblems and the Art of Law (Cambridge University Press, 2013).

The 2015 John Jay College of Criminal Justice’s Law and Literature Conference is especially interested in the following areas although all submissions will be considered.

Slavery and the Law
Armed Services (including mandatory national service/conscription/drafts) and military law
Contract workers (day laborers) and migrant workers
Sex Trade Workers and Health Care Rights
Indigenous Rights and the State
National Expansion and Immigrant Laborers
Colonial Expansion and Bound Labor
Unions and/or Contract Disputes
“Open topics” loosely connected to the conference theme will be incorporated into panels when possible Panel and Roundtable proposals should be submitted as in one email containing all participates emails as attachments

Papers  are expected be 20 minutes in length

Panel will be limited to 3 speakers, plus Chair
Important Dates
Submission Deadline:  June 30th, 2015
Notification of Acceptance: July 30th, 2015
Early Registration: September 1st, 2015
Conference Dates: October 30th, 31st, and Nov 1st

Please submit a 300-word abstract by June 30th
Please place 4LLC Abstract and your Last Name in the subject line.

Veronica C. Hendrick, Ph.D., Conference Coordinator
Associate Professor of Literature and Law
John Jay College of Criminal Justice
City University of New York

vhendrick@jjay.cuny.edu
 

Wittgenstein and Tax Law

Bret N. Bogenschneider, Vienna University of Economics and Business, has published Wittgenstein on Why Tax Law is Comprehensible in volume 252 of the British Tax Review. Here is the abstract.
The field of taxation now includes a growing body of technical language. Such tax words are not merely “labels” for various economic events (as implied by the theory of semantic formalism) as tax terminology must be contextualised consistently with Wittgenstein’s later theory of linguistics. The current debate over GAARs may constitute an example of Wittgenstein’s “signposts” which mitigate in favour of the Rule of Law and not against it. Furthermore, the proffered choice as between principles versus detail in tax legislation reflects a false dichotomy. The common averment to scepticism (or nihilism) within tax jurisprudence indicates a failure to understand the logical basis or modalities and scientific nature of tax law. The technical language of taxation is indicative of an emerging scientific discipline.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

Jack Sammons and the Parallels Between Law and Music

Joseph Vining, University of Michigan Law School, has published Jack Sammons as Therapist at 66 Mercer Law Review 335 (2015). Here is the abstract.

Jack Sammons is well known as a pioneer in making the practice of law a field of academic study and teaching. He is also an original and penetrating analyst of law as such. This essay comments on his recent work, especially his putting the way we understand law and the way we understand music side by side and drawing out the parallels between them. Many will find his work a revelation. 

Download the essay from SSRN at the link.

June 17, 2015

John Noonan As Legal Historian and Legal Philosopher

Joseph Vining, University of Michigan Law School, has published Reading John Noonan at 59 Villanova Law Review 715 (2014). Here is the abstract.
John Noonan is a giant in American law and legal practice -- a distinguished legal historian and a true judge. His reflections on the nature of law have a special importance. This essay is a comment on basic elements in his thought.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

Development of IP Regimes in the UK: The Place of Registers of Artefacts of Creation

Chris Dent, Murdoch University School of Law, has published Registers of Artefacts of Creation — From the Late Medieval Period to the 19th Century at 3 Laws 329 (2014). Here is the abstract.
This paper offers a new perspective on the “development” of the intellectual property regimes in the United Kingdom. The system put in place under the 1875 Trade Marks Act may be seen as the last of a sequence of earlier “technologies” that sought to administer the creative endeavours of (sections of) the English population. Prior to the trade mark registration (that included examination) there was the registration of designs that did not require examination but was necessary for the protection of the right. In the eighteenth century, patent specifications were lodged with the Crown via a process that was much more involved than that was instituted for designs in the nineteenth century. Before that, books had to be enrolled with the Stationers’ Company before they could be printed. And, in what may be seen as an earlier attempt at the centralised regulation of artefacts of expression, the Rolls of Arms (maintained by the King of Arms) was repository of coats of arms for English nobility. An exploration of these different technologies of regulation, in their socio-political context, will offer new insight into the antecedents, and limits, of the registration systems that are now common across the intellectual property world.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

The Regulation of Gender In Statist Czechoslovakia

Barbara Havelkova, Oxford University Faculty of Law, has published The Three Stages of Gender in Law in The Politics of Gender Culture Under States Socialism: An Expropriated Voice (H. Havelková and L. Oates-Indruchová eds.; Routledge, 2014). Here is the abstract.
Much has been written about gender in Czechoslovak state-socialist society, culture and policies, but relatively little on gender in law. The chapter offers one such analysis – it looks at how gender was regulated in law and understood and constructed by the legal community. It examines legislation, judgments, explanatory memoranda to bills, and academic legal scholarship. For reasons of space, only what was identified as comprising the ‘woman question’ by the state is assessed; namely, family (understood exclusively heteronormatively) and paid work. This results in two limitations. First, the official silence surrounding issues ignored by state policy, such as gender-based violence or LGBT rights, is not remedied in this chapter. Second, beyond areas obviously affecting women or gender relations, law is androcentric and many seemingly neutral legal institutions, such as for example self-defence in criminal law or the law of property, contain a strong male or patriarchal bias. An analysis of how this bias changed in a ‘classless’ society would be an interesting and important endeavour, but it goes beyond the scope of this chapter.

The chapter offers a diachronic analysis of state-socialist Czechoslovakia, and argues that the period of state socialism (1948-1989) was not homogeneous, but that the original equalizing zeal of the Stalinist period of the 1950s started to be challenged during the political thaw of the 1960s and became hollowed during the normalization of the 1970s and 1980s. There have been three different stages of gender equality: 1) Equalization (1948–1962); 2) Reflection (1963–1968); and 3) The era of the family (1969–1989). The existing social science literature usually discerns two periods: 1) an emancipatory, equalizing, revolutionary and activist stage of the late 1940s and 1950s; and 2) a family-oriented, conservative and stability-centred one in the 1970s and 1980s. I argue that, based on my analysis of the legal developments and legal policy debate, the period of political thaw in the 1960s needs to be assessed separately. The emergent pluralism of this time brought challenges from women (organized and individual) of the official narratives of ‘equality achieved’ but it also brought challenges from experts to the concept and policy of equality of the sexes and opened debates about the policy’s economic (in)efficiency. The period of 1960s must thus be assessed more critically from the gender perspective than it so far has been from the point of view of general political history.

My observations of a regression in the modernization of women’s status and equality during the state-socialist period, as well as the problematic pluralism of the 1960s, both allow for a more nuanced analysis of the continuities and discontinuities between state socialism and post-1989 transition. The legal framework inherited in transition came from the so-called normalization (1969-1989) – it actively supported and entrenched difference between the sexes, especially in the family. A woman was no longer the worker and active citizen of the 1950s, she was the wife who cared for her marriage and the mother who cared for her family. When claiming, in the 1990s, that gender equality needed no further attention as it had been addressed and achieved under state socialism, Czechs did not realize that what was in fact inherited was pro-family and pro-motherhood, but not necessarily pro-gender-equality policies. At the same time, what became the scarecrow in the 1990s was the earlier model of equality, exemplified by a female tractor driver of the 1950s. The transition-period rhetoric against ‘state feminism’ and forcible equality of the sexes thus distanced itself from policies that had not been current for about three decades. The 1960s also played a particular role in transition. The period of political thawing and pluralism prepared the ground for the liberalism of transition. The challenges to the efficiency of women’s work, full equality and collective childcare as well as the narrative of freedom and choice which became prominent in transition, were in some cases a re-occurrence, in some cases a continuation, of the debates which led to the Prague Spring of 1968.
Download the essay from SSRN at the link.

Impeachment, Performance Art, and the Rule of Law

Jessie Allen, University of Pittsburgh School of Law, has made available via SSRN Blind Faith and Reasonable Doubts: Investigating Beliefs in the Rule of Law, published at 24 Seattle University Law Review 691 (2001). Here is the abstract.
In the winter of 1998-99, I was in a graduate law program designed for future law teachers. I found myself thinking with new urgency about old questions: Can our legal system produce results that are at least partly independent of political and economic power? Or does the law always wind up reproducing and reinforcing the powers that be? In short, is there any such thing as the "rule of law"?

By a bizarre accident of timing, my personal inquiry into rule of law issues coincided with a new popular interest in these matters brought about by the Clinton impeachment hearings. Suddenly, there were almost daily references in the news media and on the floor of Congress to the sanctity and vulnerability of the rule of law in our democracy. I was particularly struck by the quasi-religious tone that prevailed. It seemed paradoxical to me that this most rationalist ideal should generate an aura of the sacred, and the apparent contradiction provoked me to look more closely at what we mean when we talk about believing in something.

While considering what it meant to preach the rule of law as an ungrounded article of faith, I began to wonder if there was anything about the nature of legal practice that might ground a more limited belief in law's ability to constrain power. Watching the impeachment proceedings on television, I found myself thinking about an earlier period in my life. I used to be an actress and a performance artist. It occurred to me that there were certain similarities between legal and theatrical practice.

Perhaps the formal conventions that radically limit behavior on stage and in court might be related to the decisional constraints that constitute a rule of law. That possibility, in turn, led me to ponder various kinds of limits evoked by the figure of a blind, hence limited, justice. In the end, the formalities of legal procedure seemed more central to the value of a just legal system than I had previously thought. Somehow, investigating my own tenuous -- but apparently unshakeable -- belief in a rule of law ideal changed the way I saw legal practice. This Article reports that investigation.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

Globalization and Traditional Concepts of International Law

Nico Krisch, Graduate Institute of International and Development Studies; Institut Barcelona d'Estudis Internacionals-IBEI, is publishing Pluralism in International Law and Beyond in Fundamental Concepts for International Law: The Construction of a Discipline (Jean d’Aspremont & Sahib Singh, eds., Forthcoming).
Processes of globalization are putting pressure on traditional conceptualizations of international law, and especially of its relation with domestic law and transnational norms of an informal kind. As the proximity of these different orders grows and they spur increasingly overlapping claims to authority, pluralism has become a prominent paradigm for understanding the global legal order and for guiding its development. This short overview paper traces the rise of the pluralist paradigm, its different variants and normative concerns about them, as well as some broader implications it holds for the study and practice of law.
Download the essay from SSRN at the link.

Evaluating and Appreciating Critical Race Theory and Hip-Hop: The Contributions of Richard Delgado and Ice Cube

andre douglas pond cummings, Indiana Tech Law School, is publishing Richard Delgado and Ice Cube: Brothers in Arms in volume 33 of Law and Inequality: A Journal of Theory and Practice (2015). Here is the abstract.
Critical Race Theory as a movement is best understood through the lens of founding voice Richard Delgado. Delgado’s prolific and fearless writings have inspired thousands and launched theories that have literally changed the course of race law in the United States. In fact, two explosive movements were born in the United States in the 1970s. While the founding of both movements was humble and lightly noticed, both grew to become global phenomena that have profoundly changed the world. Founded by prescient agitators, these two movements were borne of disaffect, disappointment, and near desperation — a desperate need to give voice to oppressed and dispossessed peoples. America in the 1970s bore witness to the founding of two furious movements: Critical Race Theory and hip-hop.

Critical Race Theory (CRT) was founded as a response to what had been deemed a sputtering civil rights agenda in the U.S. Driven primarily by law professors of color, it targeted the law by exposing the racial inequities supported by U.S. law and policy. Hip-hop, on the other hand, was founded by emerging artists, musicians, and agitators in the South Bronx neighborhoods of New York City, primarily driven by young African American disaffected youth, as a response to a faltering music industry and abject poverty. While these two movements, Critical Race Theory and hip-hop, seem significantly separated by presentation, content, and point of origin, they share startling similarities. Among the many similarities between Critical Race Theory and hip-hop, the closest link is the use of narrative in response to racism and injustice in a post-civil rights era. Further, Critical Race Theory and hip-hop share a fundamental desire to give voice to a discontent brewed by silence, and a dedication to the continuing struggle for race equality in the United States. Both Critical Race Theory and hip-hop strive toward their mutual goals of radical realignment and societal recognition and change of race and law in America.

One of the most important voices in the nascent days of the CRT movement was founding voice Richard Delgado, who along with Derrick Bell, introduced the world to CRT. Delgado published the explosive articles "The Imperial Scholar" and "A Plea for Narrative." Delgado’s early CRT publications represented an effort to educate and enlighten the civil-rights generation, emerging scholars of color, and the rest of the legal world to the inequities and discrimination inherent in a legal system that systematically disadvantages minority citizens in the U.S. Delgado’s voice was so important during the founding of CRT that he is revered today as a true pioneer in race jurisprudence in the United States.

Similarly, no early hip-hop voice seized the attention of both fans and critics alike the way that Ice Cube and N.W.A. did when “Straight Outta Compton” shocked the nation at its release. When Ice Cube, Eazy-E, Dr. Dre, MC Ren, and DJ Yella (as N.W.A.) released "Straight Outta Compton," the album dropped profoundly on the consciences of inner-city youth, the nation, and eventually, the globe. Never before had such an intensely angry, ferocious, rebellious record been released and embraced by the consuming public. Cuts like "Fuck tha Police," "Gangsta Gangsta," and "Straight Outta Compton" resonated with inner-city youth.

Both Ice Cube and Richard Delgado furiously challenged convention and status quo America.

Law and Aesthetics

Simon Stern, University of Toronto Faculty of Law, is publishing Effect and Technique in Legal Aesthetics in volume 2 of Critical Analysis of Law (2015). Here is the abstract.
Discussions of legal aesthetics often proceed as if it were sufficient, in exploring law’s aesthetic dimensions, to refer to effects such as symmetry, balance, and proportionality. Those effects, however, might be produced by any number of techniques, and aesthetic technique tells us more about the meaning and context of legal ideas than effects do. After discussing various kinds of inquiries into legal aesthetics, this essay turns to Blackstone’s Commentaries as a source for the techniques that inform modern legal writing and analysis.
Download the essay from SSRN at the link.

Constitutional Courts and Their Use of Foreign Law

Giuseppe Franco Ferrari, Bocconi University, has published The Use of Foreign Law by Constitutional Courts in volume 4 of the Irish Journal of Legal Studies (2014). Here is the abstract.
The essay analyses the use of foreign law by Constitutional Courts. Part I addresses the causes of the use of foreign law primarily but not exclusively within the Western Legal Tradition. Part II is devoted to the classifications of legal systems based on the method and purposes of the use of foreign precedents. Part III develops a critical analysis of traditional classifications with particular reference to Markesinis's tripartition explained and discussed in the previous Part. Finally, Part IV deals with the use of international law with a view of marking differences and similarities between the resort to foreign law and the use of international sources.
Download the Article from SSRN at the link.

June 16, 2015

This Sporting Life

Gregory S. Alexander, Cornell Law School, is publishing The Sporting Life: Democratic Culture and the Historical Origins of the Scottish Right to Roam in the University of Illinois Law Review. Here is the abstract.
In 2003, the Scottish Parliament enacted the Land Reform (Scotland) Act, which, among other reforms, grants to “everyone” a right to access virtually all land in Scotland for a wide variety of purposes, including recreation, educational activities, and even some commercial or for-profit activities. Legal recognition of this broad-ranging “right to roam” comes after more than a century of debate over the public’s right to access privately-owned land in the Scottish Highlands. This paper is the first historical account of the origins of the remarkable Scottish right to roam. It sets the debate over the right to roam with a clash between two different visions of the sporting life: One, older, rooted in the Victorian and Edwardian periods, viewed the sporting life as one of hunting, aided by the use of modern technology — rifles and such — and much older technology in the form of dogs and horses. The other vision is of more recent vintage. It is a vision of contact with nature through walking, hiking, and similar forms of unmediated interaction with nature. Curiously, both visions of the sporting life claimed the mantle of preservation and conservation. The paper argues that the culture of unmediated contact with nature ultimately prevailed as a democratic culture became more entrenched in both politics and society.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

June 15, 2015

A Novel of Cree Poetics, Love, and Heritage

Law professor Tracey Lindberg (University of Ottawa, Common Law section) has published her first novel, Birdie, a book that explores the relationships between Cree heritage and law, with HarperCollins Canada.  Read Emily Keeler's discussion of the work here in the National Post.


Tip of the beret to Kate Sutherland (Twitter).

Considering Caitlyn

David Rooney surverys the portrayal of transgender characters in film and on television in an article for the Hollywood Reporter here.

A Review of "Rethinking Modern European Intellectual History" (OUP, 2014)



Katharina Isabel Schmidt, Yale Law School, has published a review of Rethinking Modern European Intellectual History (Darrin McMahon & Samuel Moyn, eds; Oxford University Press, 2014), in Comparative Legal History (subscription may be required).   Below is an excerpt.




All too frequently, legal historians balk at projects crossing conventional geographic and/or temporary boundaries, at projects requiring minute attention to circumstantial historical detail as well as at projects flaunting disciplinary (self-)criticism. Explanations for this can be found in law’s image as an expert discipline, its association with the nation-state and its identification with at least a “modicum of metaphysicality.” Ever since the invention of writing, law has been associated with the practices of social and cultural elites. As such, it emerged as an increasingly specialized discipline, from which outsiders were excluded for their ignorance of the relevant jargon. In line with this, legal historians today frequently consider themselves to be engaged in a kind of singular, and essentially mono-disciplinary, enterprise. Historically, this trend towards scholarly autonomy was exacerbated by the fact that law came to be seen as inextricably intertwined with the nation-state. Starting with the promulgation of comprehensive codes in early modern Europe, legal rules thus began to be associated with the direct command of absolute sovereign rulers whose powers were curtailed only by the geographic and temporal boundaries of their political authority. Notably, this command-theory-based approach left little room for boundary-crossing of any kind. Finally, attempts at reproducing Maine’s intellectual legacy have traditionally run up against law’s popular association with moral truth. Though one would be hard-pressed to deny the cultural contingency of any kind of “justice-talk,” lawyers and lay-people alike often take solace and comfort in the belief that a particular rule has “absolute” or “universal” value, thus defying any sort of critical analysis.  

I now suggest that it would be distracting, if not downright dangerous, to continue to be constrained by law’s traditional association with academic expertise, the nation-state, and culturally contingent notions of what is “right.” For one, law itself is in the process of becoming more “international,” “transnational” and “global,” thus begging for a temporally and geographically more encompassing approach. Similarly, normativity in modern societies is no longer strictly and straightforwardly “legal” but, increasingly, non-positive, unofficial, relational, heterarchical, pluralistic, and informal. As a consequence, the question as to whether, and if so how, law should reflect processes of sense- and order-creation occurring naturally in society begs for answers. Finally, the simultaneous appearance and disappearance of law calls on legal scholars to adopt an altogether more critical perspective. Modern society is witnessing a bewildering tension between juridification and de-juridification. Areas that were previously subject to state regulation are gradually becoming de-regulated. Simultaneously, areas that were previously governed by people’s private-autonomous decisions are gradually being absorbed by bureaucratic, multi-level regulatory agencies. How exactly does the emergence of categories like “the international,” “the transnational,” and “the global” modify our concept(ion)s of law? And should we resist or welcome this development?"



...



As previously stated, law has traditionally been associated with expert knowledge, the nation state and justice. As a consequence, people both inside and outside the discipline perceive it as somewhat of a singular and essentially mono-disciplinary enterprise. That said, a true commitment to the methodological principles explicated by the various authors of Rethinking Modern European Intellectual History would have mandated the inclusion of law as a source of scholarly inspiration and exploration in its own right. I agree with Breckman’s view that successful interdisciplinary conversations require both sides to have learned some of the other side’s language. The question now is to what extent lawyers and historians are able and willing to do just that. I have already called on legal historians to take intellectual history seriously. This, after all, is what this review is about. I would now turn matters around and call on intellectual historians to do their part, too, which is to take law and legal ideas seriously. As detailed above, law is encroaching upon ever-new aspects of people’s day-to-day lives in an attempt to facilitate social cohesion in times of normative pluralism and fragmentation. At the same time changing conceptions of the relationship between authority and autonomy as well as growing recognition of the self-legislating abilities of economy and society have led the state to withdraw its jurisgenerative force from spheres in which it had previously played a leading role. Nevertheless, it would be naïve to assume that those very spheres are not still influenced by the remnants of law’s historically grown power and further research into the vestiges of “the legal” in supposedly law-free zones is necessary.

What follows from these considerations is that law is and has always been part of the relevant context and that, as a consequence, intellectual historians would be well-advised to take account of it. To this extent, this review preludes and makes the case for a much-needed “legal turn” in modern intellectual history. Not only does history provide a standard by which to talk critically about the law. Law provides a standard by which to talk critically about history. As such, it is time for both lawyers and historians to take one step towards each other and to aspire to disciplinary eclecticism–a kind of eclecticism, to be sure, that stays clear of the pitfalls of academic quietism.”



The First English Tontine

Moshe A. Milevsky, York University, Schulich School of Business, has published Portfolio Choice and Longevity Risk in the Late Seventeenth Century. A Re-Examination of the First English Tontine as Netspar Discussion Paper No. 06/2014-029. Here is the abstract.
Tontines and life annuities both insure against longevity risk by guaranteeing (pension) income for life. The optimal choice between these two mortality-contingent claims depends on personal preferences for consumption and risk. And, while pure tontines are unavailable in the twenty-first century, the first longevity-contingent claim (and debt) issued by the English government in the late seventeenth century offered an option to select between the two. This paper analyzes financial and economic aspects of King William's 1693 tontine that have not received attention in the financial economic literature. In particular, I compare the stochastic present value (SPV) of the tontine vs. the life annuity and discuss characteristics of investors who selected one versus the other. Finally, I investigate whether the recorded 1693 tontine survival rates -- which are abnormally high relative to population mortality rates in the late 17th century -- should be attributed to anti-selection effects or perhaps to fraudulent behaviour. In sum, this paper is an empirical examination of annuitization decisions made by investors over three hundred years ago.

Download the article from SSRN at the link.

L. Frank Baum's Allegory of Free Silver

Hugh Rockoff analyzes The Wizard of Oz as an allegory over the debate over free silver in this piece for the Journal of Political Economy (vol. 98, pp. 739-760), published in August of 1990. Here's a link, courtesy of JSTOR.

Full citation:

Hugh Rockoff, The "Wizard of Oz" as a Monetary Allegory, 98 Journal of Political Economy 739 (August 1990). 
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2937766

Contractual Unfairness In English Law, 1670-1900

Warren Swain, The University of Queensland, T. C. Beirne School of Law, has published Reshaping Contractual Unfairness in England 1670-1900 at 35 Journal of Legal History 120 (2014). Here is the abstract.
English contract law has offered protection for the vulnerable and exploited for centuries. The most wide-ranging doctrine of contractual unfairness could be found within the Court of Chancery. In Lord Nottingham's time relief extended to a range of situations, loosely held together, with no real unifying structure. Yet even here some common themes emerged. Transactions which fell outside the usury laws were looked at with particular concern. In the eighteenth century Lord Hardwicke attempted to rationalize relief under the rubric of fraud. This was largely a difference in presentation. Under the influence of the rise of legal literature and ideas derived from Will Theory, the nineteenth century might have seen the emergence of a truly coherent doctrine of contractual unfairness. That this did not happen can be attributed to a combination of factors. These include the durability of the notion of fraud, the complexity of contractual unfairness which could not be reduced to a doctrine based on will and the way in which contractual unfairness was bound up with public policy. The substance of relief may have changed less than has often been supposed. Certainly there was no shift from a world in which the courts offered protection to one in which freedom of contract always prevailed. The failure of nineteenth century judges and writers to be more radical has left a legacy of incoherence that is still felt today.
The full text is not available from SSRN.

Police In Buenos Aires in the First Half of the Nineteenth Century

Agustin Elias Casagrande, CONICET-IDIHCS-UNLP, has published 'The Active Arm of the Government' The Police of Buenos Aires in the First Half of 19th Century as Max Planck Institute for European Legal History Research Paper Series No. 2015-03. Here is the abstract.
In the first half of 19th century, the Río de La Plata was involved in a process of militarization and changing of political orders. During this time the conflictive relation between the old schemes of government and the tendency to centralize and to create new structures of power and social control was extended all across the territory. Among those Institutions thought to provide new forms of discipline, appeared the Police, created in 1812, which immediately would be involved in a tension between the local authorities and the central government. In this article, by analyzing the juridical concepts deeply rooted in legal reasoning used by the actors to create the force, it will be explained some structural elements of the meaning and logic of police order in the Spanish legal tradition (domestic government, localization, negotiation, etc.). After the study of those categories, inscribed in the legal sources which breathed life to the police´s institution, it will be examined the problems that faced the diverse attempts of building a central police-government, especially, in front of a traditional negotiable juridical culture that persisted in the mentality of the agents of Buenos Aires in the period comprehended between 1812-1853.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

Fan Fiction, Transformative Works, and Women's Voices

Elizabeth Rosenblatt, Whittier Law School and Rebecca Tushnet, Georgetown University Law Center, have published Transformative Works: Young Women's Voices on Fandom and Fair Use in eGirls, eCitizens 385 (Jane Bailey & Valerie Stevens, eds; University of Ottawa Press, 2015). Here is the abstract.

This chapter considers the transformative impact of copyright fair use and fair dealing laws on the lives of individuals based on first-person accounts of young women and girls involved in media fandom. It builds on the work of scholars who have addressed the relationship between media fandom and copyright law, and relies specifically on the voices of media fans themselves about the role that fandom, particularly the creation of noncommercial fanworks, has played in their personal and developmental lives. In so doing, it examines how exceptions to copyright exclusivity that promote remix and other transformative expression create spaces that promote girls’ self-actualization.

The chapter draws principally on fans’ responses to a call by the U.S.-based nonprofit Organization for Transformative Works for personal accounts of how creating fanworks has influenced their lives. The responses reflected young women’s views that fandom provides unique opportunities for young women and girls to connect with others, build professional and educational skills, and develop personal and emotional maturity. For example, respondents reported that through the creation of noncommercial transformative works, they found their voices; discovered unknown abilities; shared their own points of view; learned professional skills; made friends; found the strength to overcome personal hardship; and gained greater understanding of themselves and others. At the same time, fanwork creation has afforded young women and girls an audience and a unique opportunity to use existing cultural expression as a springboard to talk back to a culture that might not otherwise hear their voices. These fans’ personal accounts indicate that laws permitting the creation of noncommercial derivative works not only promote individual expression by often-marginalized speakers, but also offer particular benefits to those speakers that are not readily available through other means. The paper concludes that broad understandings of fair use, fair dealing, and other laws that promote the creation of noncommercial transformative works are beneficial not only for free expression, but also for the girls and young women who create and consume that expression.

Download the chapter from SSRN at the link.

Calling All Poets

The University of Akron Press is soliciting manuscripts for its Series in Poetry. Link here.

Tip of the beret to Carolyn D. Elias and Steve Mueske (both via Twitter).

June 14, 2015

E. M. Forster and the Internet of Things

Sidney Perkowitz discusses E. M Forster's dystopian short story "The Machine Stops" (1909), asking whether Forster anticipated the "internet of things."  Link here at JSTOR Daily.

Gender Justice and Legal Pluralities


Gender Justice and Legal Pluralities: Latin American and African Perspectives (Rachel Sieder and John Andrew McNeish eds.; Routledge Publishing, 2012) is forthcoming in paperback next month ($49.95 US).  Here is a description of the contents from the publisher's website.

Gender Justice and Legal Pluralities: Latin American and African Perspectives examines the relationship between legal pluralities and the prospects for greater gender justice in developing countries. Rather than asking whether legal pluralities are ‘good’ or ‘bad’ for women, the starting point of this volume is that legal pluralities are a social fact. Adopting a more anthropological approach to the issues of gender justice and women’s rights, it analyzes how gendered rights claims are made and responded to within a range of different cultural, social, economic and political contexts. By examining the different ways in which legal norms, instruments and discourses are being used to challenge or reinforce gendered forms of exclusion, contributing authors generate new knowledge about the dynamics at play between the contemporary contexts of legal pluralities and the struggles for gender justice. Any consideration of this relationship must, it is concluded, be located within a broader, historically informed analysis of regimes of governance.

June 12, 2015

It All Started With the Greeks

Harry Mount discusses the origins of the courtroom drama, tracing it to The Oresteia of Aeschylus. Read his article for the Telegraph here.

A New Book On Law and Emotions in the Early Nineteenth Century

Nancy E. Johnson (State University of New York, New Paltz) is the editor of  Impassioned Jurisprudence: Law, Literature and Emotion, 1760-1848, forthcoming from Bucknell University Press. Here's a link to one page on the publisher's website, although I couldn't find the book by searching for it by editor or title. Here's a description of the contents from Amazon.

This collection of essays by scholars of the law and literature movement explores the place of the passions in English law of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. While some of the essays elucidate the forces of emotion in legal texts, others consider the representation of impassioned jurisprudence in literary texts. Together these essays provide insight into the foundations of modern juridical thought.

HBO's True Detective Returns

Tim Goodman reviews the second season of HBO's True Detective here. Another review here from Variety, via the Toronto Sun.

Images of Law in Israeli and U.S. Television Shows

Itay Ravid, Stanford Law School, has published Watch & Learn: Illegal Behavior and Obedience to Legal Norms Through the Eyes of Israeli and American Popular Culture, in volume 4 of the Berkeley Journal of Entertainment & Sports Law (2015). Here is the abstract.
What do popular media tell us about the way we perceive the rule of law in our society? What conceptions of legal norms and obedience to these norms control popular mass media? How do these conceptions shape and reflect the legal culture of a given society? This paper aims to explore empirically these questions, through the analysis of American TV shows and Israeli TV shows that became popular in Israel. To achieve this goal a dual empirical strategy was adopted — content analysis of popular TV shows, and an Internet survey among Israeli respondents. This approach addresses a methodological and substantive gap in existing literature on law and popular culture since it integrates the two elements of law and popular culture that are usually treated separately — the messages conveyed in the popular artifact and the way the audience actually perceives those messages.

The content analysis seemed to reveal a disregard towards legal rules when doing so served an important interest for the characters, as well as undermining the competence of law enforcement agencies. Furthermore, the research revealed differences between Israeli and American shows, suggesting that the legal cultures of these societies may well differ. This portrayal was supported by the survey results. Moreover, the survey suggested a correlation between viewing habits and the acceptance of illegality, contributing to the evolving literature on the cultivating effects of mass media. The comparative approach of this study suggests important insights about Israeli legal culture and legal cultures in general, and raises disturbing questions about the popular notion of normative order in modern western societies in the era of globalization.

What can the apparent public contempt for legal rules tell us about the rule of law in modern democracies? Do these data provide new ways for thinking about law enforcement in an age of extreme individualism? This study sheds light on these contemporary issues. Furthermore, the study provides preliminary empirical support for the social role of popular media and its relevance in the study of cultures.
Download the article from SSRN at the link.

June 11, 2015

Readings of the Oresteia, Its Influence, and Conceptions of Law

Lukas Van den Berge, Utrecht University School of Law, and Christiaan Caspers, Radboud University Nijmege; Murmellius Gymnasium have published The Right and the Good in Aeschylus’ Oresteia and Yael Farber's Molora: Transitional Justice between Deontology and Teleology at 11 Utrecht Law Review 80 (2015). Here is the abstract.
The antagonism between deontological and teleological conceptions of law can be felt throughout the field of law. It is particularly pressing, however, in the context of what is commonly referred to as ‘transitional justice’. Should the legal response to massive violence and bloodshed be primarily a deontological one, giving primacy to the right in awarding ‘each what is his’ (suum cuique) according to a given set of principles of law? Or should this response be primarily teleological in nature, with the right being subservient to the restoration of society as a higher good? Our paper investigates this issue from the perspective of a Ricoeurian reading of Aeschylus’ Oresteia and Yael Farber’s Molora, a modern play in which Aeschylus’ story is staged against the backdrop of post-apartheid South Africa. It is argued that both the Greek original and its modern adaptation confirm Ricoeur’s view of justice as a precarious balance between Kantian deontology on the one hand and Aristotelian teleology on the other.

Download the article from SSRN at the link.